The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing -- Edmund Burke

Home  TOC  Sitemap  Search

Alerts - Petitions - Polls - Surveys

Archives  Features  Cartoons

About Us  Contact Us

Conservative Calendar of Events

Election 2002

Columnists  Guest Voices  Bios

Publishers Corner

 

It's Child Support Guidelines That Need Surgery, Not 'Deadbeat Dads'

Glenn J.Sacks & Son

Glenn J. Sacks

gsacks@americasvoices.org         
biography
archives

May 26, 2004


Kentucky judge D. Michael "Mickey" Foellger has offered men who are behind on their child support obligations a choice:  have a vasectomy or spend 30 days in jail.  However, according to a new study of child support, it is Kentucky's child support guidelines which need surgery, not so-called "deadbeat dads".

The study, "Child Support Guidelines and the Equalization of Living Standards",pdf filewas conducted by psychology professors Sanford Braver and David Stockburger and will appear in the soon to be released book The Law and Economics of Child Support Payments.  Braver and Stockburger conclude that "under current child support guidelines, the majority of custodial parents currently have higher standards of living than their matched noncustodial parents."  Of the seven states they studied, Kentucky's guidelines are among the most inequitable.

In addition to unreasonably high support levels, Kentucky noncustodial fathers also have to contend with a rigid child support system which is often impervious to the economic realities of modern life.  Fathers who are laid off, suffer wage cuts, or are injured on the job are often unable to get downward modifications on their child support.  In such cases, the amounts owed mount quickly, as do interest and penalties.

Compounding the problem is the fact that the federal Bradley amendment bars judges from retroactively forgiving child support arrearages, even when they determine that the arrearage occurred through no fault of the obligor.  As shared parenting advocates Dianna Thompson and Murray Davis of the National Family Justice Association note, "Society holds noncustodial parents, mostly fathers, to an unattainable standard to never become physically or mentally ill, never get disabled, and to never lose a job or get laid off in a poor economy."

The pot of child support gold--which hard-line judges and Attorneys General often insist they're going to find if we'd just get tough on deadbeats--simply does not exist.  Numerous studies, including the largest federally funded study of divorced fathers ever conducted, have shown that unemployment, not willful neglect, is the leading cause of child support noncompliance.

A look at Kentucky's list of top 10 "Most Wanted Parents" illustrates the point.  Far from being a list of well-heeled lawyers, accountants and bankers, only one of the 10 "deadbeats" listed appears to have any education at all, and the most common designation for occupation is "laborer".  These men do low wage and often seasonal work, and owe large sums of money which most could never hope to pay off.

Judge Foellger says his "vasectomy or jail" edict is only given to men who have fallen $10,000 behind on their child support and who have had four or more children with three or more women.  While Foellger is correct in condemning these men's irresponsible conduct, one might wonder why the mothers of their children receive neither sanction nor condemnation.  They too had kids whom they evidently cannot afford to support.

Foellger insists he's not forcing sterilization on anybody, since the offenders in his court can choose 30 days in jail instead.  However, most men who fall behind on child support have led law-abiding lives and legitimately fear for their safety and mental stability if they are incarcerated.

For example, in McCracken County earlier this year a man slit his throat in the courtroom after being sentenced to two years in jail for being $7,000 behind on child support.  According to newspaper accounts, the man pleaded to the judge "Don't put me in jail, I'm going to kill myself" before taking out a razor blade.

By threatening to jail the men, Foellger is in effect impelling them to get sterilized.  In fact, Foellger says that all but one of the men offered his "deal" have chosen vasectomy over jail.

This represents a serious human rights violation.  Kentucky's child support guidelines need to be overhauled to ensure that support obligations are in line with obligors' ability to pay.  In addition, the system needs to be more flexible and responsive, so men who are down on their luck don't become criminalized.  And while the public may be legitimately annoyed with these "deadbeats", nobody should be jailed or sterilized for the "crime" of being poor.

This column first appeared in the Cincinnati Post and the Kentucky Post (05/12/2004).

Jeff M. Leving also contributed to this article.  He is one of America's most prominent family law attorneys.  He is the author of Fathers' Rights: Hard-hitting and Fair Advice for Every Father Involved in a Custody Dispute.  Visit his website at www.dadsrights.com.

 

Copyright Copyright 2020 by Glenn J. Sacks & America's Voices, Inc.  All rights reserved.
Glenn Sacks is a nationally syndicated radio talk show host whose columns on men's and fathers' issues have appeared in dozens of the largest newspapers in the United States. 
Glenn serves on the advisory board of Stop Abuse for Everyone, an international domestic violence organization.  Glenn taught elementary school and high school in Los Angeles Unified School District and others, and was named to the "Who's Who Among America's Teachers" twice.  His radio show, His Side with Glenn Sacks, can be heard every Sunday in Los Angeles and Seattle.  Glenn invites readers to visit his website at GlennSacks.com.  You can e-mail him at Glenn@GlennSacks.com, or via gsacks@americasvoices.org.

Home  TOC  Sitemap  Search

Alerts - Petitions - Polls - Surveys

Archives  Features  Cartoons

About Us  Contact Us

Conservative Calendar of Events

Election 2002

Columnists  Guest Voices  Bios

Publishers Corner

D-Day inaugural
feature article

www.americasvoices.org
publisher@americasvoices.org
editor@americasvoices.org
webmaster@americasvoices.org

Disclaimer

Publishing Guidelines

Copyright Copyright 2020 by Americas's Voices, Inc.
Columbus, Ohio.  All rights reserved.

America's Voices, America's Voices University, americasvoices.org and www.AmericasVoices.org are service marks of America's Voices, Inc. a not-for-profit educational organization.